CSD News & Events:

News & Events - 2010


Uncovering Oscillating Patterns in Clouds

18 August 2010
image of coupled oscillating cloud system

Image: lead author Graham Feingold, NOAA and Nature

Animation of the coupled, oscillating cloud system. The open cellular structures, as represented by their liquid water path (LWP), evolve in a synchronized, periodic fashion. The precipitation generated by these clouds also has a periodic behaviour.

satellite imagery of oscillating open cells

Imagery: ICARE

Satellite imagery of oscillating open cells. Series of enhanced false colour images (1.6 μm channel) of a large marine stratocumulus cloud field in an open cellular state observed by the geostationary satellite MSG-SEVIRI in the SE Atlantic on August 18 2009. Left: larger scale perspective; the yellow box follows the mean wind so that changes therein indicate local changes in the cloud field. Right: enlargements of the yellow box in normal form (upper) and contour form (lower) showing the evolving small-scale variability at 30 min intervals. Note the flip from cloudy to clear, and back to cloudy skies again over the course of 4 hours.

image of open cellular structures

Image: lead author Graham Feingold, NOAA and Nature

Animation of open cellular structures. The view is from above, looking down on a cloud field. Updraught regions (purple) correspond to surface convergence of air, and downdraughts (green) to surface divergence of air. Initially points 1, 2, 3 and 4 occur at strong convergence zones and are favoured for the deepest clouds, and therefore the strongest rain. As time progresses, evaporating precipitation at these points creates downdraughts. On reaching the surface the air fans out and collides with neighboring pools of air that have also been driven downwards by evaporating rain. The collision between these zones creates upward moving air and new cloud formation, which in turn, produce rain with a characteristic periodicity. And so the cycle continues. Images are separated by 20 minutes.

A new NOAA study has found that rain clouds form synchronous patterns in which individual clouds in a large cloud field respond to signals from other clouds, much like chirping crickets or flashing fireflies on a summer night. The study, published online today in the journal Nature also has significant implications for our understanding of climate change research.

This research, led by CSD's Graham Feingold, shows for the first time that interactions between certain types of neighboring clouds can result in synchronized rain patterns within a large cloud system.

"Clouds organize in distinct patterns that are fingerprints of myriad physical processes," Feingold explained. "Precipitation can generate fascinating honeycomb-like patterns that are clearly visible from satellites. Cloud fields organize in such a way that their components 'communicate' with one another and produce regular, periodic rainfall events."

While the discovery of synchronized behavior in clouds is one of many recent findings on self-organization in nature, the study also examines how suspended particles, or aerosols, in the atmosphere can influence these patterns and be a factor in climate change.

The team, which also includes Ilan Koren of the Weizmann Institute, Hailong Wang of Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, Huiwen Xue of Peking University, and Alan Brewer of NOAA ESRL CSD, used satellite imagery to identify cloud systems with a "cellular, almost honeycomb-like structure." In such systems, thick clouds form the walls of the honeycomb, and cloud-free zones form the open cells between the walls. The team also observed that these cellular structures constantly rearrange themselves, with cloud walls dissolving and open cells forming in their place, while walls form where open cells once existed.

Using computer models, the scientists reproduced this rearrangement or oscillation of the cloud honeycomb pattern, and identified the driving factor – rain. Next, they analyzed scanning laser measurements from a ship cruising under cloud systems to verify their model results.

"Together, these analyses demonstrated that the rearrangement is a result of precipitation, and that clouds belonging to this kind of system rain almost in unison," Feingold said.

How does this synchronization come about? Falling rain cools the air as it descends. This creates downward air currents. These downdrafts hit the surface, flow outward and collide with each other, forming updrafts. The air flowing up creates new clouds in previously open sky as older clouds dissipate. Then the new clouds rain, and the oscillating pattern repeats itself.

"Once precipitation ensues and an open structure has formed, it is difficult to revert the cloud field to a closed-cell, or overcast state," Feingold said. "Rain keeps the oscillating, open honeycomb pattern in motion, which allows more sun to reach Earth's surface."

The scientists say that their findings point to a significant influence of particulate matter, or aerosols, on the large-scale structure of clouds and therefore on climate change. Scientists have long known that aerosols can influence local rain formation and block solar energy from reaching the Earth's surface – for an overall surface cooling effect.

However, until recently, the scientific community has not considered the self-organization that results from these effects. Computer simulations for this study indicate that high aerosol concentrations favor the formation of large, dense cloud fields with less open space and less rain. This creates a more reflective cloud pattern and cooling of the surface. Low particulate levels in computer models resulted in rain and the open honeycomb structure with an oscillating pattern. The open honeycomb structure in a large cloud field lets more sunlight reach the surface, and hence results in surface warming.

"Our work also suggests that we should expand our thinking about interactions between aerosols and clouds," Feingold said. "Integrating our current focus on fundamental physical processes with broader studies on system dynamics could give us a more complete understanding of climate change."


Graham Feingold, Ilan Koren, Hailong Wang, Huiwen Xue, Wm. Alan Brewer. Precipitation-generated oscillations in open cellular cloud fields Nature, doi:10.1038/nature09314, 12 August 2010.

Author affiliations:

Graham Feingold and Wm. Alan Brewer: NOAA Earth System Research Laboratory Chemical Sciences Division
Ilan Koren: Weizmann Institute Department of Environmental Sciences
Hailong Wang: Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
Huiwen Xue: Peking University School of Physics Department of Atmospheric Sciences

More information:

NOAA Press Release: NOAA Scientists Uncover Oscillating Patterns in Clouds